The Way Out

“There was literally nothing to do each day except wait to go to bed… It was day-to-day survival.”

Life in residential aged care isn’t the right fit for everybody – and certainly not the thousands of young Australians with disabilities who were told there was nowhere else to go. Two survivors spoke to Geraldine Mellet about their fight to get out.

Illustrations by Asher McShane


For 28-year-old Kirby Littley, life was sweet. She’d bought her own home and loved her work as a teacher for children with disabilities. But, after undergoing emergency surgery for a brain stem tumour and two subsequent strokes, her mobility and speech were hugely compromised.

Kirby needed somewhere to live and heal – but neither specialised housing nor the funding to pay for personal support were on offer. And so, despite the fact that she hadn’t even turned 30 yet, Kirby was told there was nowhere else to go but a nursing home. She says the “home” part was laughable – with the revolting smells of human waste from the pan room next door a constant reminder “that I lived in an institution”.

Historically, more than 8000 young Australians with disabilities were “placed” in residential aged care (RAC). Some were as young as 16. And the breaches of human rights that I heard from the people I spoke to, or read about in Royal Commission testimonies, were gobsmacking. Many described feeling imprisoned, stripped of choice and isolated in a universe parallel to the one they knew, with the regular heartbreak of witnessing elderly neighbours pass away.

Kirby’s ability to communicate was further complicated by a tracheotomy with a suction tube, which vacuumed out saliva so she didn’t drown. One of her only ways of alerting people – or saying no – was to wave her arms about: something the staff referred to as “behaviours” and allegedly punished her for. Kirby tells me that some staff members would refuse to push her wheelchair to the facility’s therapy block, which meant going without much-needed rehab at a time when progress was critical.

Varying standards of care also meant her life was in jeopardy more than once. She remembers one night when her ventilator wasn’t working, because the wrong tank had been attached and the water had run out. When the nurse who came to change it ignored correct procedure and turned off the unit, Kirby started to suffocate. As she waved her hands to get attention, the nurse told her off for misbehaving. In desperation Kirby pulled the trachy tube out of her throat, gasping for air through the hole in her neck.

While Kirby acknowledges some carers tried their best, the sheer volume of residents to look after meant that things like getting out of bed became a time trial, instead of an opportunity to build capacity. An extra staff member provided specifically to help Kirby shower was quickly diverted to help other residents – so, instead of being assisted to practise independent living skills, Kirby was rushed through the shower each day.

It’s no wonder that Kirby’s parents, Carol and Kevin, barely left her side during her time at the home even as they worked around the clock to make their house accessible and get their daughter out. After 12 long months, Kirby moved in.

With monumental effort in all her therapies, and the power of a mum and dad who likewise never gave up, Kirby began ticking off her goals: learning to speak again and to mobilise with a walker. Eventually she moved into her own purpose-built home, where she says she has “autonomy over what I do and when”.

Another huge milestone came some years later, when Kirby returned to work – back to the school for kids with disabilities, where her curriculum planning draws from hard-won experience she could never have guessed at previously.

Kirby’s insights have been invaluable to my work, too. She is one of three women with lived experience who read early drafts of my novel Things I Cannot Say and gave me feedback. It’s told from the perspective of a feisty 37-year-old engineer forced into a nursing home after an accident, but the fictional character would never have existed if Kirby and others hadn’t shared their own, confronting non-fictional stories.

9781038953438 48df1dae 1732 481e a382 c682b893bb89
Things I Cannot Say by Geraldine Mellet is out now

For all that she’s achieved, Kirby acknowledges the challenges that remain – including living with a brain tumour which, while currently stable, requires regular MRIs. But her goals are clear – improving her walking and talking, getting rid of the PEG feeding tube so she can eat regular food again and accomplishing even more at work.

With aged care firmly in the rear-view mirror, Kirby says she is finally “captain of her own ship”. And while their lives couldn’t have been more different, Sijan Dahal knows just how that freedom feels, too.

It only took until lunchtime on his first day at an Australian primary school that Sijan learnt the phrase, “Go back to where you came from.” Australia and its open skies and clean air were meant to be the solution to the illness that had dogged the then eight-year-old in his home town of Kathmandu, with a paediatrician advising his parents to make a life away from the city’s suffocating pollution.

With a degree in civil engineering, his father was quickly accepted into Australia’s skilled migration program. But being allowed into the country was not the same as being accepted. Dad got work in country Victoria but was quietly denied opportunities and promotion. His son fared even worse, the subject of relentless bullying that continued until he left school. By the time Sijan reached uni, he says, “The very act of existing felt wrong.”

And so, believing nothing would change, he tried to end his own life. But he survived – and waking up brought the news that he’d sustained a severe spinal cord injury. His first solid memory of the aftermath was when “a big important doctor pointed to a wheelchair and told me I’d better get used to it because it was going to be my new best friend.”

But that wasn’t the hardest part. Pushed to move out of rehab and free up a bed, he couldn’t go to his parents, who lived in an inaccessible house in a regional town with no support workers or services. Instead, his next “home” was a residential service referred to in aged care directories as a retirement home.

Sijan was 19, the youngest resident in the facility by 40 years, and found the isolation excruciating. The suburb surrounding the home was tricky for a manual chair, particularly at his stage of recovery, and he couldn’t manage the few blocks to the shops without help, which wasn’t available.

“There was literally nothing to do each day except wait to go to bed. There was no sense of community, and most workers were phoning it in,” he remembers. “I had no choice in when I woke up or what I ate, and the food was the worst. It was day-to-day survival, debating whether I was motivated to take the next bite or give up and stay in bed forever.”

TBI773-TheWayOut-FinalSpot-AsherMcShane

If his mental health was fragile before, it understandably took a huge dive in this unwelcome twilight zone. That was until Sijan found the friendship and advocacy of Deb Farrell, who worked with the Young People in Nursing Homes National Alliance. Along with other organisations such as the Summer Foundation, YPINH successfully campaigned over 25 years to change the law to stop young people being forced into RACs, as well as helping others get out and into lives of their choosing.

Deb organised temporary respite and an NDIS plan with a support coordinator. For the first time, Sijan dared to hope. But the exit pathway was a tangled web, involving a mighty legal and bureaucratic fight to access the Specialist Disability Accommodation (SDA) package that Sijan had already been granted.

Throughout this two-year period, there were five moves, mostly to motels – although, with some made unsafe by drug users, Sijan had to return to aged care. Finally, after the tribunal officially conceded he did have the right to use his original funding, Sijan moved into his own apartment. “Once the door closed and I was on my own for the first time, I knew I didn’t have to live in fear anymore. I was home and safe and settled.”

The apartment is purpose built for a wheelchair with features that, as Sijan says, “don’t make you feel like a stranger in your own place”. And there’s a concierge who can drop in to help Sijan out, whenever needed. “When I was ill with a fever of over 40 degrees, the concierge stayed and did wellness checks until the ambos came,” he says. “It gives you the dignity of independence with a safety net.”

There are two SDA apartments per floor mixed in with other neighbours, just like any other community. Across the road is a supermarket and shopping centre with doctors and other services. And within the complex is a gym, which has seen Sijan’s rehab skyrocket.

As of March 2026, the Young People in Nursing Homes Alliance estimated there were over 900 Australians under the age of 65 living in aged care – a phenomenal decrease following the campaign and new laws recommended by two Royal Commissions. But advocates are adamant they’ll continue monitoring legislative loopholes that could potentially restart the problem. And now, Sijan is among those keeping watch.

Having stability and support has enabled him to return to university, where he is studying to be a human rights lawyer and help change lives – just as Deb was able to do for him. He already works for the Tenant Voice project at the alliance and coaches others to self-advocate their NDIS appeals.

“The people that supported me when I needed it made the difference between me being here and not,” Sijan says. “Now I want to be there for someone else.”

By Geraldine Mellet
Geraldine Mellet (@Geraldine_Mellet) is a broadcast journalist, former disability advocate, late blooming novelist and lifelong reading addict. Her book Things I Cannot Say has been nominated as one of Booktopia’s Best Debut Novels 2026.

If you or someone you know needs help, please call Lifeline (13 11 14) or Beyond Blue (1300 224 636).

Visit ypinh.org.au to learn more.

Published in Ed#773

Click below to learn more


Want more of The Big Issue?
Subscribe to The Big Issue magazine to enjoy powerful journalism, stories from our vendors, and more — all delivered straight to your door.